Following Major Vote, Carlisle’s Beloved Ferns Market Could Reopen by Fall 2027

A major town vote brings Amy and Ben Pirri one step closer to reviving Carlisle’s longtime country store.

Cat Broughton
Written By Cat Broughton
News Writer
A look at the proposed interior design for the revitalized Ferns Market (Image credit: Amy and Ben Pirri)

A beloved Carlisle gathering place may soon be revived.

On Monday, November 16, a record turnout of residents at Carlisle’s Special Town Meeting overwhelmingly approved funding for the next phase of a wastewater project that could finally clear the way for Ferns Market to reopen at 8 Lowell Street in Carlisle Center. Amy and Ben Pirri, who have spent the past year and a half working to bring the longtime country store back to life, celebrated the news after more than 85% of voters supported Article 6.

“Carlisle, we are overwhelmed with gratitude. 💚 Last night was something we will never forget. A record-breaking turnout, nearly five hours together, and more than 85% of you voting YES for Ferns,” the couple shared on social media. “To everyone who showed up, stayed late, spoke up, brought your families, or simply believed in what we’re trying to accomplish – thank you.”

The vote marks an important milestone for a project that has faced its share of hurdles. Ferns closed in May 2025, leaving Carlisle without a grocery store or coffee shop. In a town without even a single traffic light, the loss of the neighborhood staple has meant residents must drive outside town for everyday essentials as simple as a bottle of water or a cup of coffee.

The property itself has a storied history. Originally built in 1844, the building has served the community in several capacities over the years, including as a gas station, post office, ice cream parlor, and lunchroom. The original store burned down twice, with the most recent reconstruction taking place in 1925.

The building’s complicated past and aging infrastructure have made its revival a significant undertaking. During its years as a gas station, the property experienced two underground fuel leaks, in 1978 and 1989. Cleanup efforts in 2000 removed more than 2.1 million pounds of contaminated soil. As part of their due diligence, the Pirris also arranged testing of the property’s soil, groundwater, and indoor air, along with water from 12 residential wells in Carlisle Center.

But the biggest obstacle has been wastewater. Since the 1990s, Ferns has operated under a state variance because its septic system is undersized. That arrangement required previous operators to monitor water usage and limit what they could prepare on-site, and the variance does not automatically transfer to a new owner. Even if the Pirris kept the existing kitchen, menu, and seating, the property would still need a permanent wastewater solution to operate long-term.

That’s where Monday’s vote comes in. According to Wicked Local, Article 6 authorizes an estimated $225,000 to $300,000 for the engineering, design, and permitting needed to connect Carlisle Center to the town’s existing wastewater treatment facility at Banta Davis. The funding covers the planning phase, not construction itself; residents will have a separate opportunity to vote on construction funding, hopefully this spring.

If that measure passes and the town establishes a construction schedule, the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection (MassDEP) has indicated it would consider allowing Ferns to reopen with a temporary holding tank while the permanent connection is built.

Last fall, the Pirris turned to the community for input, sharing a survey that drew nearly 600 responses. The results offered a clear picture of what residents would like to see in the revitalized Ferns: 86% wanted a casual gathering place, 85% favored counter service, and 76% hoped for café seating.

With those responses in mind, the couple hopes to create a space that offers a little something for everyone while preserving much of what made Ferns special. Their vision includes a well-stocked country market where customers can pick up everyday essentials, candy, beer and wine, or that one missing ingredient for dinner.

They also plan to add seating and a larger kitchen to accommodate an expanded menu for counter service and takeout. A separate takeout entrance and convenient restroom access for passing cyclists are also on the wish list, said Amy, along with a potential bar, depending on permitting.

Beyond the market itself, the Pirris hope Ferns can once again become a place where neighbors come to gather. “We’d love for seniors to have their regular coffee dates again, for kids to stop in after school, and for neighbors of all ages to come for live music on weekends,” Amy told What Now Boston. “We’d also love to have the doors open again for Old Home Day, Halloween, and the tree lighting.”

Although the Pirris’ purchase of the building depends on a successful construction vote, they’re encouraged by the community’s support and aren’t waiting to get started. The couple is moving ahead with interior architectural drawings and beginning the store’s permitting process now, hoping to make Ferns’ return possible as soon as the necessary approvals are in place.

“Last night, our neighbors showed us how much they believe in Ferns,” said Amy. “They were willing to vote ‘yes’ to invest in the design before knowing how the spring vote will go, and we feel we owe it to them to take a risk, too.”

If all goes according to plan, Ferns Market could welcome customers back by the fall of 2027. In the meantime, readers can learn more about the project at fernscarlisle.com and follow @fernscarlisle on social media for updates on the store’s progress.

Love our content?
Add WhatNow as a preferred source on Google to see more of our trusted coverage when you search.

Be the First to Know

From new restaurant openings to exciting retail launches and real estate insights, be the first to know what’s happening in Boston

Share This Article
Cat Broughton is a creative lifestyle writer and contributing reporter at What Now Media Group, where she covers new business openings and the passionate people behind them. She holds a B.A. in English from the University of Memphis and has a lifelong love of literature, which helps shape her own approach to storytelling. She currently lives in Tampa, Florida, where she spends her time writing, reading, thrifting, and seeking out good food and great fun.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *