Bagels on Fire, a beloved bagel shop in Toronto that specializes in Montreal-style bagels, is getting ready to open a new location in Liberty Village at 85 Hanna Ave.
The company’s fourth location is set to move into the former home of The Freshii, which used to serve healthy eats like wraps and bowls and closed around the beginning of 2025, according to YourCityWithin. The new Bagels on Fire is expected to open in Summer 2025, offering the same delicious Montreal-style bagels found on Queen Street and Front Street in Toronto.
Established in July 2013 by Hazel and Julio Penullar, Bagels on Fire quickly became a beloved destination in Toronto’s Beaches neighborhood. Their unwavering commitment to using only the finest ingredients and traditional baking methods sets them apart. The bagels are carefully hand-rolled and boiled in honey water, resulting in a distinctive texture and flavor profile. Custom wood-fired ovens ensure that the bagels are baked fresh daily.
When the new Liberty Village location opens this summer, customers can expect a selection of Montreal-style bagels, including plain, sesame, and everything varieties. The menu features a range of bagel sandwiches such as the Salmon Lox and Cream Cheese, and the Loaded Montreal Smoked Meat. Additionally, customers can enjoy specialty items like pretzel bagels and mini bagels. The location will also offer beverages like cold brew coffee and lemonade.
“Thanks to the support of our loyal customers, we proudly expanded to a second location on Queen St. West, sharing the joy of our wood-fired bagels with even more Toronto residents,” according to the company’s website. “And the journey continues as we look ahead to exciting plans for future growth, with new locations on the horizon. At Bagels on Fire, we hold true to our values of quality, tradition, and community. We are grateful for the opportunity to serve you and eagerly anticipate the delicious experiences that lie ahead.”
