Smithereens Team Plans New Fine-Dining Destination in the East Village

Tortoise will blend Japanese-American flavors.

Courtney McGinley Regional Reporter
The future home of Tortoise on Avenue A. (Image credit: Google Earth Pro)

A new fine-dining destination is in the works for the East Village.

Tortoise will be situated at 189 Avenue A, according to a filing with Manhattan Community Board 3.

The application lists renowned hospitality professionals Nicholas Tamburo and Nikita Malhotra as its principals.

Tamburo previously worked at Michelin-starred restaurants including Momofuku Ko, Blanca and Nishi, while Malhotra earned recognition as the Michelin Guide’s 2022 Sommelier Award winner and VinePair’s 2025 Next Wave Sommelier of the Year.

In 2024, the duo joined forces to open Smithereens, a seafood-focused restaurant in the East Village. The restaurant has earned a place in the Michelin Guide and ranked No. 18 on The New York Times’ 2026 list of the 100 Best Restaurants in New York City.

Tortoise plans to blend Japanese and American flavors throughout its cuisine.

The working menu highlights include red grouper with katsuobushi cream, fish maw and wilted brassicas; whole pigeon smoked over hay with wild mushrooms and noodles in roasted bird broth; and aged New England beef rib served with braised beef tongue, hot mustard and boiled cabbage.

The team is currently working through the permitting and licensing process.

Once open, Tortoise plans to welcome guests daily from 5:30 p.m. to midnight. Stay tuned!

Love our content?
Add WhatNow as a preferred source on Google to see more of our trusted coverage when you search.

Be the First to Know

From new restaurant openings to exciting retail launches and real estate insights, be the first to know what’s happening in New York

Share This Article
Regional Reporter
Courtney McGinley is a Regional Reporter based in Philadelphia, PA. A graduate of Penn State University's Donald P. Bellisario College of Communications, she has been working as a journalist since earning her degree. Before joining What Now Media Group, Courtney was a Live News Fellow at Newsweek, where she gained experience in writing, breaking news reporting, interviewing, and editing. She was also nominated for a Mid-Atlantic Emmy. Outside of work, Courtney enjoys cooking and exploring new restaurants, coffee shops, and cocktail bars.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *