Cousin Vinny’s Sandwich Co., the Tampa sandwich shop recognized by the Michelin Guide, is planning to double its footprint with two new restaurants. The second location is set to open in South Tampa at 4049 S. Dale Mabry Hwy. in December, followed by a third restaurant at 2063 Central Ave. in St. Petersburg in spring 2027.
The South Tampa restaurant will be a takeout-focused shop in a 1,500-square-foot space that previously housed a Pizza Hut, in a four-unit strip center near the Crunch Fitness-anchored Shoppes of South Dale. It will also serve as the company’s commissary kitchen, supporting current and future locations and helping grow its catering business. Partner AJ DeSimone said the restaurant will bring a neighborhood feel to an area of mostly corporate chains, and make it easier to reach customers who live far from the original restaurant in North Hyde Park.
The St. Petersburg restaurant will be a 1,300-square-foot space that replaces the former Little Philly. Construction is expected to wrap up in December, and the restaurant will have outdoor seating, a small rear parking lot and additional street parking. DeSimone said the company will open South Tampa first to work out the kinks before launching in St. Pete, where he sees pent-up demand.
Cousin Vinny’s started in 2023 as a ghost kitchen on North Nebraska Avenue, with pickup and delivery orders placed through its website. It opened its first brick-and-mortar restaurant on West Cass Street in North Hyde Park in early 2025, and it has been recognized in the Michelin Guide for the past two years. The flagship has made about 400 to 700 sandwiches a day, according to DeSimone.
Both new locations are hiring, and the company expects to employ roughly 100 people across all three restaurants once they are operating. Next summer, Cousin Vinny’s plans to renovate the North Hyde Park flagship to add more indoor seating.
The Tampa Bay Business Journal reported first about this development.
