After Nearly 17 Years, a Madison Street Pizzeria Bids Farewell

The Independent Pizzeria located on Madison Street announced its closure and set October 16 as its final day of service.

Written By Saheba Khatun
Representative Image, Seattle's The Independent Pizzeria is closing its doors (Image credit: Photo by Anhelina Vasylyk from Pexels)

After nearly 17 years of service, a small family-owned pizzeria in Seattle, The Independent Pizzeria, is preparing to close permanently. The owners of the pizzeria have decided to retire and hand over the restaurant space to new owners.

The Independent Pizzeria Announces Closure

The Independent Pizzeria is located at 4235 E Madison St. in Seattle’s Madison Park neighborhood. Since opening in 2010, the family-owned pizzeria has served wood-fired pizzas with a range of toppings. The restaurant specializes in wood-fired pizzas with charred crusts and varied toppings.

In a social media post, the restaurant owner shared that after nearly 17 wonderful years of service, The Independent Pizzeria will serve its last slice of pizza on October 16.

Initially, the pizzeria planned to close its doors on October 18, but in a recent post, they announced that they would be closing on Friday, two days earlier. The owner added, “We need a few extra days to pack this lil restaurant up.”

Owners Tom Siegel and Tora B. Hennessey plan to retire, prompting the closure.

With an excited tone, the pizzeria owner added, “In the meantime, we’re working on handing the space to a new owner we’re very excited about. We think they’ll be a beautiful addition to this community, and we’ll share more when it’s final.”

Community Responses on Social Media

Customers shared messages of disappointment following the closure announcement. One of the customers commented, “This is so sad to hear. I remember sitting for inside service 8 years ago to ordering takeout and eating it on the picnic tables under the lights. Thank you for some seriously awesome pizza.”

Several customers also shared heartfelt messages and wished the owners the best for their future endeavors. “Sad to hear, but so excited for you both for this new chapter! Indie forever in our hearts!!” wrote a customer.

Another customer commented, “Best wishes in retirement! Thanks for all the yummy pizzas and activism and community. Missing Indie here in SF – nothing comes close.”

As The Independent Pizzeria closes, the owners encourage the community to visit and enjoy one last slice of pizza.

Love our content?
Add WhatNow as a preferred source on Google to see more of our trusted coverage when you search.

Be the First to Know

From new restaurant openings to exciting retail launches and real estate insights, be the first to know what’s happening in Seattle

Share This Article
Follow:
Saheba Khatun is a journalist and content writer with a strong academic background in English literature and a deep passion for storytelling. She has produced a wide range of work spanning news, features, and human-interest stories, often highlighting the voices and experiences of everyday people. Known for her people-focused, thoughtful, and relatable approach, Saheba aims to inform, inspire, and foster meaningful connections through her writing. With an eye for detail and a commitment to integrity, she believes in the power of words to spark dialogue, shift perspectives, and create lasting impact. Outside of her professional work, she enjoys exploring literature, culture, and community narratives, which continue to fuel her creative process and broaden her worldview.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *