Mikey’s Late Night Slice is opening its first Cleveland-area restaurant and bar in a historic three-story building at 1898 W. 25th St. in Ohio City, with a target of sometime in 2027. CEO Mikey Sorboro said an exact date isn’t set yet given what he called the “enormity” of the rehab needed for the space.
The brand has spent more than two years searching for the right Cleveland real estate, and Sorboro said the combined investment between Mikey’s and the property owner will run past $2 million, a bigger capital lift than the company’s typical buildout. The first floor, roughly 1,700 square feet, will echo the long, narrow layout of the original Mikey’s location at High and Vine streets in Columbus. The second floor adds more seating and party space, opened up to look down onto the first floor, while the third floor will go unused.
Ohio City is already a dense hub for dining, drinking and entertainment, and the new Mikey’s shares a wall, though not a connected space, with Columbus based Pins Mechanical Co. Sorboro pointed to that proximity as a proven formula, noting Mikey’s already operates locations directly connected to Pins at both Easton Town Center and Bridge Park in Dublin.
This Ohio City spot will become Mikey’s 13th location and its first in the Cleveland market, though Sorboro said the company is also eyeing downtown Cleveland, Lakewood and other nearby areas for additional openings in 2027 and 2028. According to Columbus Business First, Mikey’s has expanded aggressively this year alone, adding restaurants in Polaris, Dayton and Grandview Heights, on top of a trio of locations that opened near Ohio State University back in 2024.
Founded in the Short North in 2009, Mikey’s built its identity on oversized New York style slices and whole pizzas, late night hours, and an irreverent attitude that shows up in everything from pizza names to its marketing.
