Mixed Fillings Pie Shop appears in a Jacksonville project filing for 2756 Park St., though it remains unclear whether the record signals a new location, a renovation or another type of project.
The filing, dated October. 20, 2026, lists Mixed Fillings at the Park Street address and identifies the project as being in the initial plan-review stage. The record does not specify the proposed work, construction cost or anticipated completion date.
The address also raises questions about the project’s connection to the business. Mixed Fillings opened a downtown Jacksonville location at 440 W. Adams St. in March 2025, celebrating the opening on Pi Day. Additional confirmation is needed to establish whether the Park Street filing relates to a separate location or another project involving the business.
Founded by chef Natasha Burton, Mixed Fillings is known for its handmade sweet and savory pies, offering a range of flavors for customers looking for something beyond traditional pie varieties. The business has developed a following in Jacksonville for its creative approach to the dessert staple.
The shop also received national recognition through USA Today’s 10Best readers’ poll, ranking No. 3 among the country’s best pie shops in 2025 and No. 7 in 2026.
For now, the project filing does not confirm that Mixed Fillings is opening another storefront or renovating an existing one. Further details about the address and proposed work would be needed to determine what the project means for the business.
WhatNow Jacksonville will provide updates as more information becomes available.
